Rubric

Hands-on Practical Foods Analytic Rubric

With hands-on activities, it is important to practice great safe working habits which includes group and individual participation. In your groups, each member will have a role/task to follow/complete. As an individual, you will also be responsible to communicate and support others in your group.

rubric-symbol

A analytic rubric is a valuable and practical tool to assess students hands-on process of the proper procedures/techniques used in a safe manner to complete their final food project product. By applying the knowledge taught, following procedures and techniques, co-operating and communicating with your team/group will allow you to build your skills, and habits and show those qualities in the rubric assessment. Remember though, the levels are just approximate chunks of how well you did in each of the assessment criteria area levels being measured, and gives you tangible feedback and direction on your product and more importantly your process. This process is broken down into specific category areas as previously discussed: knowledge & understanding, communication, thinking & inquiry, and application where marks will be applied.

Mark Level Equivalent Values
Assessment
Criteria
Column


Criteria
Below
Level 1

0-49%

Poor
Level 1

50-59%


Fair
Level 2

60-69%


Good
Level 3

70-79%


Great
Level 4

80-100%


Excellent
Overall Cooking Lab Evaluation
Overall Performance

Proper terminology, techniques, preparation, procedures, safety & sanitation, cleaning and cooking processes demonstrating responsible and safe work habits, co-operation, collaboration, professionalism and maturity, open communication, and leadership, in the kitchen lab with duties and responsibilities throughout the cooking process and and finished food product.
 
Poor

No effort, unacceptable behavior or use of equipment, not with assigned group, and/or didn't do assigned kitchen duties.

 
Fair

Lack of effort, improper behavior or use of equipment, wandered out of assigned group, or didn't do assigned kitchen duties.
 
Good

Participated with only minimal effort, tendency to wander, minimal cleanup effort, skill level needs improvement.
 
Great

Practiced good teamwork skills, completed all personal, pre-prep, and prep skills, completed kitchen duties, shows professionalism, good attitude, shows creativity, practices good techniques.
 
 
Excellent

Shows leadership skills within group and class, shows professionalism, mastered techniques, shows creativity, completes assigned jobs and kitchen duties.
 
 
Group Cooking Process 75%
Preparation & Planning

Prepared and organized ahead of time with equipment, utensils, measuring tools, recipe, ingredients, allocated time, knowhow and refinements/variations if necessary. Having all ingredients measured, cooking steps ready and understood, watching time allocation and getting finished on time.
 
Poor

Little prepared and was not organized with several of the tasks, measurements, and tools needed. Practiced poor time management and very few of the recipe steps and ingredient measurements were done correctly.
Fair

Partly prepared and organized with a few of the tasks, measurements, and tools needed. Practiced fair time management and completed a few of the recipe steps and ingredient measurements correctly.
Good

Prepared and organized with some of the tasks, measurements, and tools needed. Practiced good time management and completed some of the recipe steps and ingredient measurements correctly. Attempts to support and assist peers.
 
Great

Prepared and organized with most of the tasks, measurements, and tools needed. Practiced great time management and completed most of the recipe steps and ingredient measurements correctly. Some peer support and assistance.
 
Excellent

Prepared and organized with all of the tasks, measurements, and tools needed. Practiced excellent time management and completed all recipe steps and ingredient measurements correctly. Successfully supports/assists peers and showed excellent leadership initiatives and skill.
 
Safety & Sanitation

Practiced proper safety and sanitation techniques, both before and after cooking. Clean workstation, work habits, and appropriate personal wear/apron.
 
Poor

Demonstrated poor safety and sanitation practices before, during, and after the food preparation using poor work habits and techniques.
 
Fair

Demonstrated fair safety and sanitation practices before, during, and after the food preparation using fair work habits and techniques.
 
Good

Demonstrated good safety and sanitation practices before, during, and after the food preparation using good work habits and techniques. Attempts to support and assist peers.
 
Great

Demonstrated great safety and sanitation practices before, during, and after the food preparation using great work habits and techniques. Some peer support and assistance
 
 
Excellent

Demonstrated excellent safety and sanitation practices and initiatives before, during, and after the food preparation using excellent work habits and techniques. Successfully supported and assisted peers.
 
Equipment & Techniques

The use of kitchen resources, equipment, utensils, measurement devices, and work area properly, with the preparation of food.
 
Poor

Demonstration of poor techniques and skills using workstation area, most equipment, utensils, and measuring devices.
 
 
Fair

Demonstration of fair techniques and skills using workstation area, some of the equipment, utensils, and measuring devices.
 
 
Good

Demonstration of good techniques and skills using workstation area, most equipment, utensils, and measuring devices. Attempts to support and assist peers.
 
Great

Demonstration of great techniques and skills using workstation area, equipment, most utensils, and measuring devices. Some peer support and assistance
 
 
Excellent

Demonstration of excellent techniques and skills using workstation area, all equipment, utensils, measuring devices, and successfully supports/assists peers showing excellent leadership skills.
 
Cooking Process

Follows and completes recipe instructions correctly with appropriate and safe techniques as demonstrated by the teacher, resulting in a food product..
 
Poor

Demonstrated poor cooking techniques, professionalism, completing little recipe instructions successfully in a timely manner with no peer support/assistance.
Fair

Demonstrated fair cooking techniques, professionalism, completing some recipe instructions successfully in a timely manner with little peer support/assistance.
Good

Demonstrated good cooking techniques, professionalism, completing several recipe instructions successfully in a timely manner with attempts to support and assist peers.
Great

Demonstrated great cooking techniques, professionalism, completing most recipe instructions successfully in a timely manner with some peer support and assistance
 
Excellent

Demonstrated excellent cooking techniques, professionalism, completing all recipe instructions successfully in a timely manner with successful peer leadership, support, and assistance.
 
Co-operation & communication

Working and communicating well with your group and instructor.
 
Poor

Demonstrating consistent lack of cooperation and communication with group with little or no support for others
 
Fair

Demonstrating some cooperation and/or communication with group and instructor, with some initiative.
 
Good

Demonstrating good cooperation and communication with group and instructor, showing good initiative and some leadership support.
 
Great

Demonstrating great cooperation and communication with group and instructor, with a lot of initiative and leadership skills.
 
Excellent

Demonstrating consistent excellence in cooperation and communication with group and instructor, showing excellent initiative and leadership.
 
Final Product

Your finished food dish.
 
Poor

Burnt or way under cooked with an unappetizing appearance, texture with little followed and recipe not turning out.
 
Fair

Over/under cooked with an unappetizing appearance, taste, and/or texture with recipe partially followed/turned out.
 
Good

Slightly over/under cooked with an moderate appetizing appearance with a decent taste and texture as per most recipe instructions/goal
 
Great

Cooked properly with an appetizing appearance with a great taste and texture as per recipe instructions/goal
 
Excellent

Cooked to perfection with an appetizing appearance, a delicious taste and texture as per recipe instructions/goal
 
Clean up

Ensuring all work areas, equipment, utensils, towels aprons are cleaned, sanitized if necessary, and properly put away making it ready for the next group cooking
 
Poor

Work area dirty and not sanitized, including counter top, stove/oven, sink, microwave,areas Little put away and/or clean/dry dishes, utensils, cutting boards and dirty towels/aprons. Others need to help as your clean-up not done properly.
 
Fair

Work area somewhat clean and some areas sanitized including most counter top, stove/oven, sink, microwave,areas. Put away and clean/dry some dishes, utensils, cutting boards, dirty towels, and aprons in with little sense of time.
 
Good

Work area relatively clean and most areas sanitized including counter top, stove/oven, sink, and microwave,areas. Put away and clean/dry most dishes, utensils, cutting boards, dirty towels, and aprons in a timely manner with some peer assistance.
 
Great

Work area pretty clean and sanitized including most counter top, stove/oven, sink, and microwave,areas. Properly put away and clean/dry most dishes, utensils, cutting boards, dirty towels, and aprons in a timely manner with some peer support and assistance.
 
Excellent

Work area is clean and sanitized including counter top, stove/oven, sink, microwave areas. Properly put away and clean/dry dishes, utensils, cutting boards, dirty towels, and aprons in a timely manner with excellent initiative and leadership.
 
Duties and Responsibilities

Responsible role, tasks, and procedures that need to be completed, as part of the group, to effectively complete the group cooking process safety.
 
Poor

Group members did not complete all of their duties safely in the cooking process with little procedures done correctly.
 
 
Fair

Group members completed most of their duties safely in the cooking process with some procedures not entirely correct.
 
Good

Group members took the initiative to complete their duties, responsibilities and procedures safely and worked to support some other duties, in the cooking process and some peer support.
 
Great

Group members took the initiative to complete their duties, responsibilities and procedures correctly in a safe manner, worked well to support other duties, in the cooking process setting an some great examples and peer support.
 
Excellent

Group members not only completed their duties, responsibilities and procedures correctly in a safe manner, but also took an initiative and ensured overlap and support for other duties in the cooking process, setting an excellent example and leadership skills.
 
Individual Grading 25 %
Duties and Responsibilities

Completion of all kitchen duties.
 
Poor

Student completed little or no assigned kitchen duties.
 
Fair

Student completed only a few kitchen duties.
 
Good

Student completed some kitchen duties.
 
Great

Student completed most kitchen duties.
 
Excellent

Student completed kitchen duties and helped other students as needed.
 
Citizenship

Mature professional aittude and safe practices with group members and instructor.
 
Fail

Student exhibited little or no safe practices such as use of equipment, towels, respect, behavior and/or wondering.
 
Fair

Student exhibited several unsafe practices such as improper use of equipment, towels, respect, wondering and/or behavior.
 
Good

Student exhibited some unsafe practices such as improper use of equipment, towels, wondering, or behavior.
 
Great

Student showed safe practices and behavior.
 
Excellent

Student exhibited excellent safety and behavior and set a great example for the group/class.